The whole lot we love about basic store-bought desserts—assume acquainted packaged favorites—however with a selfmade twist! These 12 copycat desserts to make at dwelling recreate well-known treats with from-scratch taste and bakery-style upgrades. From selfmade Oreos to frosted brown sugar cinnamon Pop-Tarts, I’m assured you’ll discover at the very least one favourite price baking once more.

You know the way one chew of a sure dessert can immediately carry again recollections?
Over time, I’ve created many recipes impressed by well-liked treats everyone knows and love—the snacks and sweets you’d usually seize off the shelf, however made proper in your individual kitchen. When a craving hits for one thing acquainted, recreating it at dwelling with actual substances and recent taste is a enjoyable and satisfying possibility. That’s precisely what this checklist is about!
After I consider the treats that outlined my childhood snack drawer, cookies at all times come to thoughts. Recipes for oatmeal cream pies, skinny mint cookies, selfmade Oreos, and peanut butter cookie sandwiches channel the originals—simply with richer taste, higher texture, and that unmistakable selfmade contact.


If a deal with with the unbeatable mixture of chocolate cake + cream filling was your go-to, meet my chocolate cake roll and cream-filled chocolate cupcakes. The latter is one in all my all-time favourite recipes. A lot in order that I included it in my New York Instances best-selling cookbook, Sally’s Baking 101. You simply can’t beat a basic!
I’d be remiss to not embody one of many final copycat classics: Pop Tarts—particularly frosted brown sugar cinnamon pop tarts. Making your individual from scratch at dwelling is simpler than you assume with my step-by-step photographs and video tutorial. They’re normally thought of a breakfast deal with, however these completely rely as dessert in my guide.

Q: What’s your favourite copycat dessert recipe? Are there any others that you simply’d wish to see on my website? Let my crew and I do know within the feedback part under!
12 Copycat Desserts to Make at House
Selfmade Skinny Mint Cookies
A selfmade model of the favored Lady Scout favourite! These are fantastic when you possibly can’t get your arms on the true factor!
Selfmade Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop Tarts
These utterly from scratch pop tarts are made with my well-liked all-butter pie crust and a dreamy brown sugar and cinnamon filling.
Cream-Crammed Chocolate Cupcakes
These are moist and deeply chocolatey cupcakes stuffed with fluffy whipped vanilla buttercream, and topped with a wealthy 2-ingredient chocolate ganache.
Selfmade Oatmeal Cream Pies
Made with buttery cinnamon-kissed oatmeal cookies and a fluffy, candy cream filling, I’m assured you’ll discover that these selfmade oatmeal cream pies are even higher than the unique.
Chocolate Cake Roll (Swiss Roll)
A nod to the basic childhood favourite, this chocolate cake roll combines gentle chocolate sponge cake with candy vanilla whipped cream and chocolate ganache. The supreme dessert alternative for chocolate lovers each younger and younger at coronary heart!
Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches (Similar to Nutter Butters)
Whereas these crispy but chewy cookies are undeniably scrumptious, the thick, creamy peanut butter filling is the true star that can have you ever coming again for extra.
Iced Oatmeal Cookies
These iced oatmeal cookies are old school type with buttery delicate facilities, crisp chewy edges, loads of cozy spice taste, and a lightweight coating of vanilla icing to seal the deal.
Selfmade Oreos
With solely 10 minutes of dough-chilling time and no rolling pin required, making a batch of those iconic sandwich cookies is faster and simpler than you assume.
Mini Animal Cracker Cookies
Flip a easy 8-ingredient sugar cookie recipe into cinnamon-kissed selfmade mini animal cracker cookies. High with icing and rainbow sprinkles.
Household-Favourite Rice Krispie Treats Recipe
The addition of somewhat additional butter and marshmallow, plus a splash of vanilla extract and a pinch of salt, units my rice krispie recipe aside from all the remaining.
Ice Cream Cake (Select Your Taste)
This crowd-pleasing deal with combines two of your favourite ice cream flavors, plus layers of Oreo cookies, selfmade sizzling fudge, and whipped cream. Harking back to the frosty muffins you purchase out of your favourite ice cream retailer.












