Peanut Butter Eggs (Reese’s Eggs)

This publish might comprise affiliate hyperlinks. Please see my full disclosure for particulars.

Hello Daring Bakers!

WHY YOU’LL LOVE THIS RECIPE: My pleasant Selfmade Peanut Butter Eggs (Reese’s Eggs) shall be your new favourite Easter sweet. The all-natural creamy peanut butter filling takes just a few minutes to combine—they’re virtually as straightforward as grabbing some from the shop, and a lot extra scrumptious! 

• Everybody’s favourite mixture: Assume Reese’s, however higher! These are naturally sweetened and have a richer, deeper taste.
• No baking required: No sweet thermometer wanted both. Simply make the filling, soften the chocolate, dip, and beautify!
• Easy pantry components: It’s wonderful how kitchen fundamentals can flip into such a particular deal with.
• Nice household mission: Extra enjoyable than dyeing Easter eggs, and clearly a lot tastier.
• Freezer-friendly: Freeze these selfmade peanut butter eggs for as much as three months!

When my son George woke me up just a few years in the past at 6:30 am, craving Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (mother life!), it led me to create a more healthy selfmade model. Even higher, George helped me make them and was so pleased with his accomplishment. That second led me to develop a straightforward, festive Easter model we may make collectively, and my Selfmade Peanut Butter Eggs (Reese’s Eggs) are simply as fairly as they’re scrumptious. This nostalgic Easter favourite is ideal tucked into Easter baskets, organized on a dessert desk, or wrapped up as a candy selfmade present.

My prime tip: don’t skip the freezing step! The peanut butter heart should be frozen for at the least an hour so that they maintain their form when dipped in chocolate. Work with just a few at a time, hold the remaining within the freezer so that they don’t soften earlier than you possibly can coat them.  For extra cute and scrumptious Easter recipes, try my Chocolate Easter Eggs, Child Chick Vanilla Cupcakes, and Chocolate Mousse Pots with Strawberry Carrots.

Desk of Contents

What are Selfmade Peanut Butter Eggs (Reese’s Eggs)?

My Selfmade Peanut Butter Eggs (Reese’s Eggs) is a from-scratch model of the sweet retailer basic. The treats function creamy peanut butter, almond flour, and maple syrup facilities formed into eggs, coated in chocolate, and embellished with piped Sweet Melts and colourful sprinkles. The peanut butter cup was invented by H.B. Reese within the Nineteen Twenties, and the corporate invented their seasonal peanut butter Easter egg in 1966.

Key Substances and Substitutes

Salted easy peanut butter

• Salted easy peanut butter is the bottom of the filling. It provides the sweet a creamy texture and a wealthy, nutty taste.
• I like to recommend utilizing a Skippy-type peanut butter for the precise consistency.
  • If you happen to use pure or “drippy” peanut butter, it’s possible you’ll have to stir in an additional teaspoon of almond flour.
• The pure fat in peanut butter assist hold the filling strong when it’s chilled.
• Substitutes: Use the identical quantity of almond butter in case you favor.
  • For a nut-free possibility, use the identical quantity of sunflower butter.

Maple syrup

• Maple syrup provides this wholesome Reeses deal with pure sweetness and a be aware of caramel depth.
• Moreover, the maple syrup contributes to a easy, cohesive filling.
• Substitute: You too can use the identical quantity of agave syrup.

Almond flour

• Almond flour thickens the filling of this peanut butter egg recipe so it holds its form.
• Importantly, almond flour absorbs moisture, making the combination moldable reasonably than sticky.
• Not like the powdered sugar (confectioners’ sugar) utilized in some recipes, almond flour provides a wealthy, nutty taste and helps hold the filling from being too candy.
• Substitutes: You should utilize the identical quantity of very finely crushed Graham crackers or digestive biscuits.

Salt

• Salt enhances the filling components and creates a satisfying distinction with the candy chocolate.

Chopped milk chocolate

• Milk chocolate makes a easy outer shell that coats the peanut butter heart.
• Utilizing milk chocolate creates the proper distinction between the nutty, barely salty heart and the candy coating.
• It’s essential to make use of chopped chocolate right here as a result of chocolate chips comprise stabilizers that hold them from melting easily.
• Substitutes: Use chopped semi-sweet or darkish chocolate if you would like a coating that’s not so candy.

Vegetable oil

• Vegetable oil thins the chocolate, so it types a easy, shiny coating for the chocolate eggs.
• Importantly, the oil helps hold the chocolate from changing into too thick, making the dipping course of less complicated.
• Substitute: Use the identical quantity of coconut oil.

Sweet Melts and sprinkles (optionally available)

• Sweet Melts, colourful confectionery wafers that soften and can be utilized for piping, drizzling, or dipping, are a straightforward method so as to add candy, colourful decorations. It hardens and will get shiny because it units.
• Use sprinkles for a further layer of festive colour.
• Substitutes: You too can drizzle additional milk chocolate on the eggs and add chopped nuts or flaked coconut in case you like.

The right way to Make Selfmade Peanut Butter Eggs

Make the Peanut Butter Egg Filling

1. Put together the trays: Line two small trays with parchment paper and put aside.
2. Combine filling: In a medium bowl, stir collectively the peanut butter, maple syrup, almond flour, and salt till totally mixed.

4. Let thicken: Let the peanut butter combination relaxation for 10 minutes to permit the combination to thicken.

5. Form filling: Divide into 16 parts (about 1 ½ tablespoons every), mould into egg form, and flatten barely.

6. Freeze till agency: Place on one baking sheet and freeze for 1 hour, till agency.

Make the Chocolate Coating

6. Mix coating components: In a microwave-safe bowl, mix the milk chocolate and vegetable oil.
7. Microwave to soften: Microwave in 30-second intervals, stirring between every, till melted and easy. Alternatively, soften over a double boiler.

Coat the Peanut Butter Eggs

8. Coat peanut butter eggs: Working in small batches and holding the remaining frozen, dip the formed peanut butter eggs within the melted chocolate, then carry it out with a fork.

9. Place on tray: Faucet the fork gently on the sting of the bowl to take away extra chocolate, then place the coated egg in your different ready tray.

10. End coating: Repeat with the remaining eggs.

Embellish the Peanut Butter Eggs

11. Put together Sweet Melts: Soften the Sweet Melts of your selection in accordance with the package deal instructions and fill piping baggage fitted with small spherical suggestions. (You too can simply use any leftover chocolate from coating the eggs.)
12. Embellish: Pipe your required decorations and add sprinkles whereas the melts are nonetheless moist.

13. Put in fridge to set: Refrigerate till the decorations are set, about half-hour.

FULL (PRINTABLE) RECIPE BELOW! 

Gemma’s Professional Chef Suggestions

• Use salted peanut butter for one of the best taste. Salted peanut butter will give one of the best stability of flavors, however you should utilize unsalted in case you favor.
• Clean peanut butter is less complicated to form. We like to make use of easy peanut butter in these Reeses eggs, as a result of it’s simpler to make use of when forming the egg-shaped facilities,  however be at liberty to make use of crunchy if that’s your desire.
• Almond butter is an possibility. You may exchange the peanut butter with almond butter or another nut butter that you just want.
• Preserve the filling frozen.  Conserving the selfmade peanut butter eggs frozen earlier than dipping them will make them simpler to deal with and cut back the danger of them falling aside.
• You should utilize semisweet or darkish chocolate right here as a substitute of milk chocolate for the coating.
• Don’t neglect the oil: The small quantity of oil retains the coating easy and helps stop bloom, however leads to a softer set, so it’s best to maintain the eggs refrigerated.
• Faucet off the surplus chocolate drip: This step retains the coating from being too thick.
• Don’t overheat the chocolate: Warmth in 30-second interval, or warmth gently in a double-boiler.
• Use for dessert trays, candy buffets, or as a cute placecard holder: My selfmade peanut butter eggs additionally make the proper edible Easter present.

Make-Forward and Storage Suggestions

Make-Forward Suggestions

• You may make and form the peanut butter filling upfront, wrap or place in an hermetic container, and refrigerate for in the future earlier than dipping.
• You too can make the peanut butter eggs forward, place them in an hermetic container, utilizing parchment paper between the layers, and refrigerate for as much as 2 weeks.
  • For extra prolonged storage, freeze for as much as three months.
  • Thaw in a single day within the fridge earlier than serving.

The right way to Retailer Leftovers

• Retailer leftovers for as much as two weeks in an hermetic container within the fridge.
  • Place parchment paper between the layers if stacking the eggs.
• For extra prolonged storage, freeze for as much as three months.
  • Thaw within the fridge in a single day earlier than serving.

Combine-Ins and Adorning

• Add some crunch: Use crunchy peanut butter, or add finely chopped toasted nuts to the filling combination.
• Make it mini: You may make these eggs any measurement you need! 32 mini eggs could be actually cute too.
• Festive shapes: Take the filling combination, roll between sheets of parchment, and use cookie cutters to chop out shapes.
• Easy adorning: If you happen to’re brief on time, merely drizzle the leftover chocolate over the eggs and add sprinkles earlier than the chocolate dries.

FAQs

Can I take advantage of pure peanut butter?

• I like to recommend utilizing a Skippy or Jif-type peanut butter. Pure peanut butter is looser and oilier, so your filling will not be simply moldable.
  • If you happen to do use pure peanut butter, stir it effectively first.
  • Moreover, in case your filling is simply too mushy, add one other teaspoon of almond flour.
  • Freeze the filling for an further quarter-hour.

Why is my filling too mushy?

• The consistency needs to be like cookie dough—thick sufficient to mould and hold its form.
• In case your filling is simply too mushy, freeze it for one other quarter-hour.
• If it’s nonetheless too mushy, and in case you used pure peanut butter, stir in one other teaspoon of almond flour.

What chocolate is finest to make use of?

• Use chopped chocolate for melting.
  • Don’t use chocolate chips. They’re made with stabilizers, which hold them from melting easily.
• If you happen to don’t wish to use milk chocolate, you should utilize semi-sweet or darkish chocolate as a substitute.

How do I get a easy chocolate coating for my Reeses peanut butter eggs?

• To get a easy chocolate coating to your Reeses peanut butter eggs, make sure to use the quantity of vegetable oil known as for.
• Regardless that it’s a small quantity of oil, it’s essential to creating the right easy texture.
• If the filling begins melting throughout dipping, the chocolate is simply too scorching. Let it cool for a couple of minutes earlier than persevering with with dipping.

Extra Easter Dessert Recipes