If, as Tolstoy wrote, each completely satisfied household is alike, he forgot to say that each completely satisfied household can screw up birthdays in several methods. When you multiply the variety of individuals in our completely satisfied household (me, my husband, Howie, and our two sons, Bruno and Leon) by, let’s say 20 years, you get 80 methods of differentiating ourselves from each different completely satisfied household that’s having a crappy time on these completely satisfied events.
I got here to the occasion with baggage. I used to be born on April Fools’ Day. Someplace there’s a residence film of me, at two years outdated, blowing out the candles on a cake formed like a lamb with coconut fur. I bear in mind nice childhood desserts, desserts that I ate with harmless pleasure till I used to be sufficiently old to study that the day—the me day—was a cultural sensible joke. “Oh, is it your birthday? I forgot. Ha ha, April Fools!”
Howie has his personal annual trauma, his birthday coming ten days after his family members had blown all their cash on Christmas. Bruno and Leon had been born 4 years and three days aside, and there was no answer to the birthday-proximity drawback that prevented one child from feeling the opposite’s day had been extra enjoyable. All 4 of us appear to share a discovered or genetic aversion to having “Glad Birthday” sung to us in a public setting.
At times, we’ve gotten it proper. Howie’s sixtieth was a shock that really labored. All of our pals gathered on a winter night time in a comfy Airstream trailer that features as a personal eating room for a restaurant referred to as Diner in Brooklyn. Howie was genuinely shocked and delighted. Every of my sons has had a memorable dinner—a sushi extravaganza for Leon, a steakhouse blowout for Bruno. Since Leon acquired married 4 years in the past, I’ve been saying that every one I would like for my birthday are my daughter-in-law Jenny’s chiles rellenos (the perfect I’ve ever had).
However as this previous April approached, I’d realized—poor me!—that I used to be the one one who’d nonetheless not had a memorable household birthday. The answer was easy: I’d kidnap Howie, Bruno, Leon, Jenny, and our three-year-old granddaughter, Emilia, to a different metropolis the place no less than two of the most typical occasion ruiners—somebody couldn’t get off work, somebody needed to be out of city—had been unlikely to happen.
I stated, “How about Miami?” Leon stated, “How about Joe’s Stone Crab?” Giant, loud, convivial, and a 97-year-old South Seaside establishment, Joe’s is the form of place about which you would possibly say, “Nicely, you don’t go there for the meals”—besides that you just do. As a result of the meals is wonderful.
With its no-reservations coverage, Joe’s ensures you hang around on its nice patio, ready fora desk and ingesting till, by the point you’re seated, the room glows with the lambent golden aura of a wonderful wine buzz.

Like their office, Joe’s waiters are old-school, and so they’ve mastered the steadiness between gracious service and dictatorial management. Our man appeared like a bouncer—a grumpy bouncer who, by some miracle, knew exactly what we wished, beginning with the truth that we didn’t wish to make any choices. The menu has choices, like a decadent crab pot pie, however everybody knew we had been there for the king stone crab claws, steamed and served chilly, with the standard sides: hashed brown potatoes, creamed spinach, and coleslaw.
When the platters of crab claws arrived, it was apparent that 97 years of experience had gone into making ready these glistening pyramids of crustacean perfection. The claws had been tender, juicy, and candy. The meat loosened from the shells with the best steadiness of reluctance and give up. The marvelous hash browns coated the entire crispy-soft vary, and the humorous pucker factor that creamed spinach does to the within of your mouth made me surprise what genius first realized how nicely it will go along with crab. The coleslaw, a hillock of cabbage with tomato-slice bulkheads, was celestial.
Likely there are courageous souls who eat crab at enterprise lunches, however I’m the reticent kind who feels that every one that twisting and sucking and slurping is finest accomplished within the firm of shut pals, lovers, or blood relations. We took turns feeding Emilia, who cherished the crab, potatoes, and coleslaw, although not a lot the spinach.
Somebody will need to have talked about it was my birthday, however I used to be so delirious with meals, wine, and pleasure that I didn’t thoughts when a candle arrived on a dice of cake and everybody, even the waiter, sang “Glad Birthday.” Emilia sang the loudest, and I used to be glad to assume we hadn’t handed our birthday drawback on to the following era.
I appeared down on the desk and, as if by magic, there have been plates of the tangy Key lime pie for which Joe’s is justly well-known. “Thanks,” I stated. “I like you all.” I cherished the Key lime pie. I even cherished the waiter. Emilia ate all my cake and a few pie. Then she stated, “The place’s the piñata?”


