I Don’t Like Pizza Rankings… However Right here Are My High 10 NEPA Pizzas of 2025
Whereas I assessment pizza each inside and outdoors of Northeastern Pennsylvania, this listing is NEPA solely. After releasing a earlier listing that included pizzerias exterior my conventional assessment footprint, I skilled some fairly robust suggestions. I listened—and this 12 months, we’re maintaining it native.
In the course of the 2025 calendar 12 months, I reviewed 95 pizzas. There have been lots of nice ones, a handful that missed the mark, and every part in between. You received’t see the unhealthy pizzas on my social media, and that’s intentional. If I don’t have one thing optimistic to say, I merely don’t say it in any respect. My purpose has all the time been to highlight one of the best pizza our space has to supply—so with that stated, listed here are 10 of one of the best pizzas I ate in NEPA in 2025.
Scoring Methodology
Though my pizza critiques are written to explain the pizza fairly than scale back it to a quantity, I do preserve meticulous scores behind the scenes in a spreadsheet.
Every pizza is evaluated utilizing a 10-point scale throughout a number of classes. The general rating is usually a median of those standards, although I’ll sometimes regulate up or down if I really feel one datapoint unfairly skews the outcome.
Since founding NEPA Pizza Evaluation in 2012, I’ve scored each pizza utilizing the identical core classes:
- Crust
- Sauce
- Cheese
- Style
- Crispy/Cooked Correctly
- Worth
These scores mix to kind an General Rating, which helps me monitor consistency and evaluate pizzas throughout kinds and visits.
Why I hate Pizza Scores and Rankings and High 10 Lists
Right here’s the reality: I don’t imagine a single quantity can precisely describe how good—or unhealthy—a pizza is. A rating tells you little or no past a reviewer’s opinion in numerical kind.
I’m additionally not an enormous fan of rankings. Any considered one of these pizzas may outrank one other on a unique day, underneath totally different circumstances. And rating pizzas that aren’t even remotely related—totally different kinds, ovens, toppings, or intentions—might be short-sighted at greatest.
But… right here I’m.
So Why Publish a High 10 Checklist?
Since you requested for it. Repeatedly.
Over time, I’ve acquired an amazing variety of requests from readers to provide this actual sort of content material. So for as soon as, I’m stepping exterior my consolation zone.
This text is my 2025 pizza leaderboard—revealed so that you can learn, debate, critique, and argue about within the feedback. That dialog is a part of the enjoyable.
What This Pizza Rating Is (and Is Not)
This isn’t a complete listing of each pizzeria I’ve ever reviewed.
It’s not a declaration of “one of the best pizza in NEPA.”
And it’s not meant to be greater than it’s.
That is merely an inventory of the High 10 pizzas I personally ate, reviewed, and scored in NEPA throughout 2025. I didn’t attempt every part. I didn’t get in all places. I’m simply sharing the trays that stood out essentially the most to me this 12 months.
Take it for what it’s—my opinion. Be happy to share yours!
NEPA Pizza Evaluation’s High 10 Pizzas of 2025
#10. Antonio’s Pizza – Nanticoke, PA
- Pizza Ordered: Hen Wing Sicilian Pizza
- General Rating: 8.2
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#9. The Man With the Dough. – Moosic, PA
- Pizza Ordered: New York Model Pizza
- General Rating: 8.2
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#8. D’Amore Pizza – Taylor, PA
- Pizza Ordered: Candy Chili Hen Sicilian (Sq.) Pizza
- General Rating: 8.2
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#7. DaVinci Pizza on the Sq. – Scranton, PA
- Pizza Ordered: Grandma Pizza
- General Rating: 8.2
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#6. Colarusso’s Coal Fired Pizza – Dickson Metropolis, PA
- Pizza Ordered: Spherical Pizza (NY/Neapolitan Model) with sweeter sauce
- General Rating: 8.5
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
Wish to discover one of the best pizza sauce within the grocery retailer? I style examined, reviewed and rated a ton of canned pizza sauces! Try my Finest Pizza Sauce Article!
#5. Lupo Rosso Pizza Truck
- Pizza Ordered: Sicilian Pizza
- General Rating: 8.5
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#4. Cafe Apizza – Forty Fort
- Pizza Ordered: New Haven Model Pizza
- General Rating: 8.5
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
Store on Amazon to Help NEPA Pizza Evaluation!
Wish to make wonderful Detroit model pizza or Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza at dwelling? Try my favourite pizza pans by Lloypans! I exploit them always. Clicking on this affiliate hyperlink prices you nothing, however I’ll earn a small fee that helps my mission of bringing publicity to domestically owned small companies!
#3. Anthony’s Restaurant – Previous Forge
- Pizza Ordered: Skinny Crimson Previous Forge Tray
- General Rating: 8.6
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#2. Dino’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant Wyoming Valley Mall – Wilkes-Barre, PA
- Pizza Ordered: Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza
- General Rating: 8.7
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
#1. Gio’s Pizza Co. – Clarks Summit & Dickson Metropolis, PA
- Pizzas Ordered: New Haven Model Cheese Pizza and Sourdough Sicilian
- General Rating: 9.1 (New Haven) and eight.9 (Sourdough Sicilian)
- Click on Right here to see the complete assessment
Gio’s Pizza Co takes my high spot for 2025! New Haven model pizza positively arrived in NEPA in 2025 in an enormous method. You may see that Cafe Apizza additionally opened in 2025 with their tackle Apizza. Hogan’s Heroes in Dallas was the primary to place New Haven pizza on the menu. For me, Gio’s Pizza Co in Clarks Summit earned the highest spot with the legendary model of New Haven model to Northeastern PA, and it received the Bar Pazzo Huge Monday competitors 🏆 With that signature char, chewy crust, and daring tomato taste, Gio’s Apizza is popping heads—and turning doubters into believers.
So what can we study from a high 10 listing like this? Effectively, this listing supplies perception into the highest 10 pizzas that I rated highest in 2025 – that’s it! Sure, it’s true, I go to some pizzerias commonly as I personally take pleasure in their model of pizza and order it extra typically in my private life. Additionally it is true that a number of of those pizzerias I’ve visited in prior years. Is there a good method to title a high 10 pizzas of something? In my view there is no such thing as a excellent method to do it. That is fairly merely the ten highest rated pizzas that I attempted in NEPA 2025. Nothing extra, nothing much less.
Do I extremely advocate every of the ten pizzerias on this listing? Completely, they’re all unbelievable pizzas and I believe they’re worthy of touring a distance to attempt them. I additionally imagine there are numerous different pizzerias that I visited that you simply also needs to attempt! Try my pizza map to discover a pizzeria close to you that I like to recommend!
The massive query is, the place ought to I go to in 2026? Who will make the highest 10? Hit me up on Fb and let me know your suggestions!
